Allegheny College vs Arcadia University
Side-by-side college ROI comparison from College Scorecard data
Verdict
Allegheny College has a 100.0% graduation rate compared to Arcadia University at 100.0%. Average median debt: Allegheny College at $25,268 vs Arcadia University at $26,428. Average first-year post-graduation earnings: $58,700 vs $55,700.
| Metric | Allegheny College | Arcadia University |
|---|---|---|
| Graduation Rate | 100.0% | 100.0% |
| School Type | Private | Private |
| State | Pa | Pa |
| Avg Median Debt Average median debt across all tracked majors | $25,268* | $26,428 |
| Avg 1yr Earnings Average first-year earnings across all tracked majors | $58,700* | $55,700 |
| Majors Tracked | 20 | 20 |
| Best ROI Major | Computer Science (95/100) | Computer and Information Sciences (95/100) |
| Best Major Debt | $22,029* | $22,352 |
| Best Major 1yr Earnings | $95,000 | $95,000 |
Allegheny College has a 100.0% graduation rate compared to Arcadia University at 100.0%. Average median debt: Allegheny College at $25,268 vs Arcadia University at $26,428. Average first-year post-graduation earnings: $58,700 vs $55,700.
Explore More
Completion rates run close at the two schools: 100.0% versus 100.0%. When graduation probability is comparable across both options, the decision comes down to cost and post-graduation earnings rather than degree-completion risk.
Debt loads run similar between the two schools — averages of $25,268 and $26,428 respectively. With debt comparable, the financial decision essentially reduces to the earnings side: which degree, from which school, produces the better post-graduation income trajectory.
Earnings outcomes track closely — Allegheny College and Arcadia University graduates report similar first-year wages. The school decision in cases like this is usually decided on non-financial axes (program quality, geography, fit) since the ROI math runs close enough to be inside the noise.
Both schools sit in Pa, which simplifies the in-state-vs-out-of-state tuition question and aligns the regional labor markets students will enter post-graduation. Cross-school comparisons within the same state should weight program mix and employer-pipeline depth heavily — the cost-of-living and labor-market backdrop is effectively held constant, so program-level differences are the differentiator.
Source: U.S. Department of Education College Scorecard, 2026.